Most Disputed Games Ranked

These games rank highest on disagreement between AI analysis and community votes. Strong splits reflect conversation, not objective truth.

1. #1

   

   Baldur's Gate III(2023)

   Dispute41AI: 16 · 45 votes

   Peak GamingHighly disputed

   Users often cited: Forced diversity / representation · Modern agenda in established franchise

2. #2

   

   Mixtape(2026)

   Dispute39AI: 18 · 35 votes

   Peak GamingHighly disputed

   Users often cited: Forced diversity / representation · Identity over story

3. #3

   

   Pragmata(2026)

   Dispute35AI: 10 · 21 votes

   Peak GamingHighly disputed
4. #4

   

   Dragon Age: The Veilguard(2024)

   Dispute35AI: 20 · 9 votes

   Peak GamingHighly disputed

   Users often cited: Forced diversity / representation · Identity over story

5. #5

   

   Red Dead Redemption 2(2018)

   Dispute33AI: 11 · 10 votes

   Peak GamingHighly disputed

   Users often cited: Modern agenda in established franchise · Political messaging

6. #6

   

   Undertale(2015)

   Dispute28AI: 13 · 10 votes

   Peak GamingHighly disputed
7. #7

   

   Horizon Forbidden West(2022)

   Dispute24AI: 18 · 5 votes

   Peak GamingHighly disputed
8. #8

   

   Super Mario Bros.(1985)

   Dispute24AI: 91 · 4 votes

   Certified Woke TrashHighly disputed
9. #9

   

   The Last of Us: Left Behind(2014)

   Dispute23AI: 15 · 3 votes

   Peak GamingHighly disputed
10. #10

    

    Citizen Sleeper(2022)

    Dispute21AI: 42 · 6 votes

    Slightly WokeHighly disputed
11. #11

    

    Hollow Knight(2017)

    Dispute21AI: 4 · 5 votes

    Peak GamingDisputed
12. #12

    

    Hitler vs Jews(2023)

    Dispute21AI: 100 · 2 votes

    Certified Woke TrashHighly disputed
13. #13

    

    Jesus Simulator(2022)

    Dispute21AI: 96 · 2 votes

    Certified Woke TrashHighly disputed
14. #14

    

    ROBLOX(2006)

    Dispute21AI: 4 · 2 votes

    Peak GamingHighly disputed
15. #15

    

    SEX with HITLER 2(2022)

    Dispute21AI: 100 · 2 votes

    Certified Woke TrashHighly disputed
16. #16

    

    Subnautica(2018)

    Dispute20AI: 4 · 4 votes

    Peak GamingHighly disputed
17. #17

    

    Hades(2020)

    Dispute20AI: 8 · 2 votes

    Peak GamingHighly disputed
18. #18

    

    Overwatch 2(2022)

    Dispute19AI: 27 · 4 votes

    Very Little WokeHighly disputed
19. #19

    

    Genshin Impact(2020)

    Dispute19AI: 13 · 2 votes

    Peak GamingHighly disputed
20. #20

    

    Gothic 1 Remake(2026)

    Dispute19AI: 11 · 2 votes

    Peak GamingHighly disputed
21. #21

    

    Hades II(2025)

    Dispute19AI: 13 · 2 votes

    Peak GamingHighly disputed
22. #22

    

    Mario Bros. (1983)(1983)

    Dispute19AI: 91 · 2 votes

    Certified Woke TrashHighly disputed
23. #23

    

    Celeste(2018)

    Dispute18AI: 12 · 27 votes

    Peak GamingHighly disputed

    Users often cited: Forced diversity / representation · Political messaging

24. #24

    

    1348 Ex Voto(2026)

    Dispute18AI: 15 · 2 votes

    Peak GamingHighly disputed
25. #25

    

    Disco Elysium(2019)

    Dispute15AI: 31 · 3 votes

    Very Little WokeDisputed
26. #26

    

    Dungeons of Hinterberg(2024)

    Dispute15AI: 18 · 2 votes

    Peak GamingDisputed
27. #27

    

    DELTARUNE

    Dispute14AI: 25 · 26 votes

    Very Little WokeHighly disputed
28. #28

    

    007 First Light(2026)

    Dispute14AI: 67 · 22 votes

    Very WokeHighly disputed
29. #29

    

    Calico(2020)

    Dispute14AI: 3 · 2 votes

    Peak GamingDisputed
30. #30

    

    Slay the Spire(2019)

    Dispute14AI: 0 · 2 votes

    Peak GamingHighly disputed
31. #31

    

    Ages of Conflict: World War Simulator(2022)

    Dispute14AI: 0 · 1 vote

    Peak GamingDisputed
32. #32

    

    Blender (Software)(2012)

    Dispute14AI: 0 · 1 vote

    Peak GamingDisputed
33. #33

    

    Bloons TD 6(2018)

    Dispute14AI: 0 · 1 vote

    Peak GamingDisputed
34. #34

    

    Football Manager 2024(2023)

    Dispute14AI: 0 · 1 vote

    Peak GamingDisputed
35. #35

    

    Forza Horizon 4(2018)

    Dispute14AI: 0 · 1 vote

    Peak GamingDisputed
36. #36

    

    Outbound(2026)

    Dispute14AI: 0 · 1 vote

    Peak GamingDisputed
37. #37

    

    Ultrakill(2020)

    Dispute13AI: 3 · 11 votes

    Peak GamingHighly disputed
38. #38

    

    Starfield(2023)

    Dispute13AI: 37 · 5 votes

    Very Little WokeHighly disputed
39. #39

    

    Bloodborne: The Old Hunters(2015)

    Dispute13AI: 3 · 3 votes

    Peak GamingDisputed
40. #40

    

    Pizza Tower(2023)

    Dispute13AI: 4 · 3 votes

    Peak GamingDisputed
41. #41

    

    Black Myth: Wukong(2024)

    Dispute13AI: 8 · 2 votes

    Peak GamingDisputed
42. #42

    

    Hollow Knight: Silksong(2025)

    Dispute13AI: 4 · 2 votes

    Peak GamingDisputed
43. #43

    

    Albion Online(2017)

    Dispute13AI: 3 · 1 vote

    Peak GamingDisputed
44. #44

    

    Brawl Stars(2018)

    Dispute13AI: 1 · 1 vote

    Peak GamingDisputed
45. #45

    

    Cave Story+(2010)

    Dispute13AI: 5 · 1 vote

    Peak GamingDisputed
46. #46

    

    Changed(2018)

    Dispute13AI: 3 · 1 vote

    Peak GamingDisputed
47. #47

    

    Deep Rock Galactic(2020)

    Dispute13AI: 3 · 1 vote

    Peak GamingDisputed
48. #48

    

    Guild Wars 2(2012)

    Dispute13AI: 6 · 1 vote

    Peak GamingDisputed
49. #49

    

    Half-Life 2(2004)

    Dispute13AI: 5 · 1 vote

    Peak GamingDisputed
50. #50

    

    Half-Life: Alyx(2020)

    Dispute13AI: 6 · 1 vote

    Peak GamingDisputed