IS IT WOKE?

Most Disputed Games Ranked

These games rank highest on disagreement between AI analysis and community votes. Strong splits reflect conversation, not objective truth.

The ranking

Titles are ordered for this games list. Open any entry for the full score and reasons. Current leaders: Halo Campaign Evolved, Hitler vs Jews and Baldur's Gate III.

  1. Halo Campaign Evolved
    Halo Campaign Evolved(2026)
    Dispute43AI: 31 · 34 votes
    Very Little WokeHighly disputed

    Users often cited: Modern agenda in established franchise · Forced diversity / representation

  2. Hitler vs Jews
    Hitler vs Jews(2023)
    Dispute43AI: 100 · 9 votes
    Certified Woke TrashHighly disputed
  3. Baldur's Gate III
    Baldur's Gate III(2023)
    Dispute41AI: 16 · 100 votes
    Peak GamingHighly disputed

    Users often cited: Forced diversity / representation · Modern agenda in established franchise

  4. Red Dead Redemption 2
    Red Dead Redemption 2(2018)
    Dispute41AI: 11 · 18 votes
    Peak GamingHighly disputed

    Users often cited: Political messaging · Forced diversity / representation

  5. Super Mario Bros.
    Super Mario Bros.(1985)
    Dispute41AI: 91 · 11 votes
    Certified Woke TrashHighly disputed
  6. Mixtape
    Mixtape(2026)
    Dispute39AI: 51 · 43 votes
    Slightly WokeHighly disputed

    Users often cited: Forced diversity / representation · Identity over story

  7. Pragmata
    Pragmata(2026)
    Dispute35AI: 10 · 28 votes
    Peak GamingHighly disputed
  8. Undertale
    Undertale(2015)
    Dispute35AI: 13 · 22 votes
    Peak GamingHighly disputed

    Users often cited: Forced diversity / representation · Preachy dialogue

  9. Dragon Age: The Veilguard
    Dragon Age: The Veilguard(2024)
    Dispute35AI: 20 · 11 votes
    Peak GamingHighly disputed

    Users often cited: Forced diversity / representation · Identity over story

  10. Horizon Forbidden West
    Horizon Forbidden West(2022)
    Dispute35AI: 18 · 10 votes
    Peak GamingHighly disputed

    Users often cited: Forced diversity / representation · Forced strong female lead

  11. Elden Ring
    Elden Ring(2022)
    Dispute34AI: 6 · 8 votes
    Peak GamingHighly disputed
  12. God of War: Ragnarök
    God of War: Ragnarök(2022)
    Dispute29AI: 16 · 5 votes
    Peak GamingHighly disputed
  13. The Last of Us: Left Behind
    The Last of Us: Left Behind(2014)
    Dispute29AI: 15 · 5 votes
    Peak GamingHighly disputed
  14. Gothic 1 Remake
    Gothic 1 Remake(2026)
    Dispute27AI: 11 · 5 votes
    Peak GamingHighly disputed
  15. New Super Mario Bros.
    New Super Mario Bros.(2006)
    Dispute27AI: 91 · 5 votes
    Certified Woke TrashHighly disputed
  16. Dungeons of Hinterberg
    Dungeons of Hinterberg(2024)
    Dispute26AI: 18 · 5 votes
    Peak GamingHighly disputed
  17. ROBLOX
    ROBLOX(2006)
    Dispute26AI: 4 · 4 votes
    Peak GamingHighly disputed
  18. World of Warcraft
    World of Warcraft(2004)
    Dispute24AI: 5 · 3 votes
    Peak GamingHighly disputed
  19. Mario Bros. (1983)
    Mario Bros. (1983)(1983)
    Dispute23AI: 91 · 5 votes
    Certified Woke TrashHighly disputed
  20. Super Smash Bros. Melee
    Super Smash Bros. Melee(2001)
    Dispute23AI: 91 · 5 votes
    Certified Woke TrashHighly disputed
  21. Diablo IV
    Diablo IV(2023)
    Dispute23AI: 8 · 3 votes
    Peak GamingHighly disputed
  22. Citizen Sleeper
    Citizen Sleeper(2022)
    Dispute22AI: 42 · 8 votes
    Slightly WokeHighly disputed

    Users often cited: Forced diversity / representation · Political messaging

  23. Dishonored 2
    Dishonored 2(2016)
    Dispute22AI: 11 · 3 votes
    Peak GamingHighly disputed
  24. Hollow Knight
    Hollow Knight(2017)
    Dispute21AI: 4 · 6 votes
    Peak GamingDisputed
  25. Jesus Simulator
    Jesus Simulator(2022)
    Dispute21AI: 96 · 4 votes
    Certified Woke TrashHighly disputed
  26. Calico
    Calico(2020)
    Dispute21AI: 3 · 3 votes
    Peak GamingHighly disputed
  27. SEX with HITLER 2
    SEX with HITLER 2(2022)
    Dispute21AI: 100 · 2 votes
    Certified Woke TrashHighly disputed
  28. Subnautica
    Subnautica(2018)
    Dispute20AI: 4 · 4 votes
    Peak GamingHighly disputed
  29. Tiny Tina's Wonderlands
    Tiny Tina's Wonderlands(2022)
    Dispute20AI: 14 · 4 votes
    Peak GamingHighly disputed
  30. Hades
    Hades(2020)
    Dispute20AI: 8 · 3 votes
    Peak GamingHighly disputed
  31. Kenshi
    Kenshi(2018)
    Dispute20AI: 4 · 3 votes
    Peak GamingHighly disputed
  32. League of Legends
    League of Legends(2009)
    Dispute20AI: 5 · 3 votes
    Peak GamingHighly disputed
  33. Hades II
    Hades II(2025)
    Dispute19AI: 13 · 5 votes
    Peak GamingHighly disputed
  34. Overwatch 2
    Overwatch 2(2022)
    Dispute19AI: 27 · 5 votes
    Very Little WokeHighly disputed
  35. Genshin Impact
    Genshin Impact(2020)
    Dispute19AI: 13 · 4 votes
    Peak GamingHighly disputed
  36. Rift of the NecroDancer
    Rift of the NecroDancer(2025)
    Dispute19AI: 11 · 2 votes
    Peak GamingHighly disputed
  37. The Last of Us Part I
    The Last of Us Part I(2022)
    Dispute19AI: 12 · 2 votes
    Peak GamingHighly disputed
  38. Celeste
    Celeste(2018)
    Dispute18AI: 12 · 56 votes
    Peak GamingHighly disputed

    Users often cited: Forced diversity / representation · Identity over story

  39. Deltarune: Chapter 2
    Deltarune: Chapter 2(2021)
    Dispute18AI: 57 · 7 votes
    Slightly WokeDisputed
  40. 1348 Ex Voto
    1348 Ex Voto(2026)
    Dispute18AI: 15 · 5 votes
    Peak GamingHighly disputed
  41. Sea of Stars
    Sea of Stars(2023)
    Dispute18AI: 11 · 3 votes
    Peak GamingHighly disputed
  42. Silent Hill f
    Silent Hill f(2025)
    Dispute18AI: 14 · 3 votes
    Peak GamingDisputed
  43. Terraria
    Terraria(2011)
    Dispute18AI: 0 · 3 votes
    Peak GamingDisputed
  44. Apex Legends
    Apex Legends(2019)
    Dispute18AI: 13 · 2 votes
    Peak GamingHighly disputed
  45. Palworld
    Palworld(2024)
    Dispute17AI: 24 · 7 votes
    Very Little WokeDisputed
  46. Ready or Not
    Ready or Not(2023)
    Dispute17AI: 18 · 2 votes
    Peak GamingHighly disputed
  47. Fear & Hunger
    Fear & Hunger(2018)
    Dispute16AI: 17 · 3 votes
    Peak GamingDisputed
  48. Metal Gear
    Metal Gear(1987)
    Dispute16AI: 4 · 3 votes
    Peak GamingDisputed
  49. Portal 2
    Portal 2(2011)
    Dispute16AI: 5 · 2 votes
    Peak GamingDisputed
  50. Disco Elysium
    Disco Elysium(2019)
    Dispute15AI: 31 · 5 votes
    Very Little WokeDisputed

How this list works

Dispute score measures AI vs community disagreement (and vote split when available). Titles need both an AI score and a community signal. Run the backfill script to populate cached disputeScore columns.

Related lists