Most Disputed Books Ranked

These books rank highest on disagreement between AI analysis and community votes. Strong splits reflect conversation, not objective truth.

The ranking

Titles are ordered for this books list. Open any entry for the full score and reasons. Current leaders: Mein Kampf, The Communist Manifesto and Mein Kampf.

  1. Mein Kampf
    Dispute35AI: 100 · 5 votes
    Certified Woke TrashHighly disputed
  2. Dispute31AI: 100 · 4 votes
    Certified Woke TrashHighly disputed
  3. Mein Kampf
    Dispute30AI: 100 · 6 votes
    Certified Woke TrashHighly disputed
  4. The Handmaid's Tale
    Dispute24AI: 80 · 4 votes
    Very WokeHighly disputed

    Question-style page

  5. Blood Meridian
    Dispute16AI: 22 · 3 votes
    Very Little WokeDisputed
  6. Bible
    BookBible
    Dispute14AI: 0 · 7 votes
    Essential ReadingHighly disputed
  7. Dispute14AI: 100 · 1 vote
    Certified Woke TrashDisputed
  8. Teach Yourself Dutch Dictionary
    Dispute14AI: 0 · 1 vote
    Essential ReadingDisputed
  9. Dispute14AI: 100 · 1 vote
    Certified Woke TrashDisputed
  10. The Iliad
    Dispute14AI: 0 · 1 vote
    Essential ReadingDisputed
  11. Willmington's Guide to the Bible
    Dispute14AI: 0 · 1 vote
    Essential ReadingDisputed
  12. Benim Kahramanim Türk Halkidir
    Dispute13AI: 94 · 1 vote
    Certified Woke TrashDisputed
  13. So long, and thanks for all the fish
    Dispute13AI: 5 · 1 vote
    Essential ReadingDisputed
  14. The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy
    Dispute13AI: 5 · 1 vote
    Essential ReadingDisputed
  15. Transgender
    Dispute13AI: 99 · 1 vote
    Certified Woke TrashDisputed
  16. Bi-Curious Gay Porn
    Dispute12AI: 11 · 1 vote
    Essential ReadingDisputed
  17. Crime and Punishment
    Dispute12AI: 8 · 1 vote
    Essential ReadingDisputed
  18. Dune, Dune Messiah, Children of Dune
    Dispute12AI: 10 · 1 vote
    Essential ReadingDisputed
  19. Empire of the Vampire
    Dispute12AI: 10 · 1 vote
    Essential ReadingDisputed
  20. Mostly Harmless
    Dispute12AI: 11 · 1 vote
    Essential ReadingDisputed
  21. The Catcher in the Rye
    Dispute12AI: 11 · 1 vote
    Essential ReadingDisputed

    Question-style page

  22. Dispute12AI: 13 · 1 vote
    Essential ReadingDisputed
  23. Dispute12AI: 11 · 1 vote
    Essential ReadingDisputed
  24. Yüzbinlerin Sürgünü Kırım'da Türk Soykırımı
    Certified Woke TrashDisputed
  25. Red Rising
    Dispute11AI: 15 · 2 votes
    Essential ReadingDisputed
  26. Dispute11AI: 81 · 1 vote
    Certified Woke TrashDisputed
  27. Moana
    BookMoana
    Dispute11AI: 19 · 1 vote
    Essential ReadingDisputed
  28. Dispute11AI: 18 · 1 vote
    Essential ReadingDisputed
  29. The One and Only Ivan
    Dispute11AI: 16 · 1 vote
    Essential ReadingDisputed
  30. Trump
    BookTrump
    Dispute11AI: 18 · 1 vote
    Essential ReadingDisputed
  31. Web van angst
    Dispute11AI: 18 · 1 vote
    Essential ReadingDisputed
  32. 1920 Adana Ermeni mezalimi hâtıraları
    Dispute10AI: 78 · 1 vote
    Very WokeDisputed
  33. Dispute10AI: 97 · 1 vote
    Certified Woke TrashDisputed
  34. Very WokeDisputed
  35. A Tale for the Time Being
    Dispute9AI: 30 · 1 vote
    Very Little WokeDisputed
  36. Very WokeDisputed
  37. Dispute9AI: 32 · 1 vote
    Very Little WokeDisputed
  38. Dispute8AI: 37 · 1 vote
    Very Little WokeDisputed
  39. The Big Meat
    Dispute8AI: 65 · 1 vote
    Very WokeDisputed
  40. The gift of rain
    Dispute8AI: 17 · 1 vote
    Essential ReadingDisputed
  41. Gravity's Rainbow
    Dispute7AI: 59 · 1 vote
    Slightly Woke
  42. Dispute7AI: 57 · 1 vote
    Slightly Woke
  43. The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo
    Dispute7AI: 44 · 1 vote
    Slightly Woke
  44. Avatar The Last Airbender
    Dispute6AI: 11 · 1 vote
    Essential Reading
  45. The Fault in Our Stars
    Dispute6AI: 13 · 1 vote
    Essential Reading
  46. A Psalm for the Wild-Built
    Dispute5AI: 57 · 1 vote
    Slightly Woke
  47. Absolute Martian Manhunter
    Dispute5AI: 41 · 1 vote
    Slightly Woke
  48. Decision Points
    Dispute5AI: 44 · 1 vote
    Slightly Woke

How this list works

Dispute score measures AI vs community disagreement (and vote split when available). Titles need both an AI score and a community signal. Run the backfill script to populate cached disputeScore columns.

Send feedback

We send your description, report type, optional email and the current page path. No browsing history or session transcript is included.