IS IT WOKE?
FIFA poster
Game

FIFA

2017

43Score
Concerning Cash-Grab Signs

Several sourced extraction signals remain unresolved.

What counts as a cash grab?

Commercial extraction prioritized over meaningful consumer or creative value. Profit, popularity, adaptations, sequels, remakes, high budgets, and normal marketing do not count by themselves.

Why?

FIFA 18 on Nintendo Switch (2017) shipped as a bespoke Switch build that omitted the Frostbite engine and several modes present on PS4 and Xbox One, notably The Journey and some Ultimate Team features. Multiple reviews and reporting describe the Switch edition as effectively a Legacy/last-generation style release with roster updates and platform-specific controls, while EA marketed bespoke Switch features such as split Joy-Con support. Critics highlighted the reduced feature set and questioned full-price positioning, while some outlets praised the portable, responsive gameplay.

  • Switch edition did not use Frostbite and omitted The Journey and other features.
  • Reviews characterize the Switch release as a Legacy/last-generation style build with minimal new gameplay changes.
  • EA marketed Switch-specific control and portability features despite the pared-down feature set.
View full breakdown
  • Multiple reviewers and outlets said charging full price for the limited Switch version was a weak value proposition.

Score factors

DirectionFactorEvidenceImpact
ForLegacy engine reuseThe Switch edition was built on a non-Frostbite, legacy-style engine and resembles older PS3/Xbox 360 'Legacy Edition' builds rather than the current-gen Frostbite version.[1][3][2]+23
ForMissing modes and featuresCritics reported the Switch version lacked The Journey story mode, some Ultimate Team features such as Squad Battles, and the EA Sports Football Club functionality.[1][5]+13
ForFull price concernsMultiple reviews and outlets argued the Switch release was a tough sell at full price because it lacked features that other platforms received.[6][8][7]+12
ForMarketing emphasized Switch buildEA's official marketing promoted FIFA 18 as 'built for Nintendo Switch' with split Joy-Con support and unique play options while platform reporting noted core content present on other platforms was missing.[4][1]+11
ForTrailer and disclosures noted engine differencesEA and promotional materials (and the trailer) explicitly noted the Switch build did not run on Frostbite, and reporting flagged that omission as the reason for other content being absent.[2][10]+8
AgainstPortable performance and controlsSeveral reviews praised the Switch build for delivering responsive portable gameplay, Joy-Con support, and a solid on-the-go FIFA experience that differed positively from last-generation ports.[9][1]-8
AgainstLocal social and control optionsEA and reviewers noted Switch-specific features like split Joy-Con play and various local multiplayer configurations which provided consumer-friendly portability and social play benefits.[4][1]-5

Confidence: High · Multiple reputable reviews, the official EA product page, and contemporaneous reporting directly document the engine differences, missing modes, marketing claims, and pricing concerns, though internal EA development decision details are not public. · Researched 2026-09-30

Sources reviewed

View 31 more sources

What does the community think?

The AI found concerning cash-grab signs. What's your read?

Loading community verdict…

Run FIFA through another test

Did they use AI?Evidence tracker
Back to the woke verdict

Send feedback

We send your description, report type, optional email and the current page path. No browsing history or session transcript is included.