
Anthem
2019
The sourced concerns are substantially offset by delivered value.
What counts as a cash grab?
Commercial extraction prioritized over meaningful consumer or creative value. Profit, popularity, adaptations, sequels, remakes, high budgets, and normal marketing do not count by themselves.
Why?
Anthem launched in February 2019 as a BioWare/EA live service looter shooter that received mixed reviews for repetitive endgame, technical problems, and limited content. Reporting from Kotaku and contemporaneous reviews document development turmoil and deadline pressure that left many systems unfinished. EA and BioWare publicly stated microtransactions would be cosmetic only, and BioWare later stopped major rework plans (Anthem NEXT) in February 2021. The evidence shows rushed development and weak post‑launch support, while direct proof of predatory monetization or deceptive pricing is absent.
- Independent reporting documents last‑minute development pressure and leadership churn during Anthem’s production, indicating a rushed build at launch.
- Major outlets and reviewers criticized Anthem’s lack of endgame variety and technical issues, supporting a consumer value gap at release.
- EA and BioWare repeatedly stated microtransactions were cosmetic only and no loot boxes would be added, reducing evidence of predatory in‑game monetization.
View full breakdownHide full breakdown
- BioWare announced cancellation of the planned Anthem NEXT rework in Feb 2021, showing the publisher halted long‑term overhaul investment.
Score factors
| Direction | Factor | Evidence | Impact |
|---|---|---|---|
| For | Critics cited lack of content and repetitive endgame | Major reviews described strong moments but a thin endgame, repetitive mission design, and unmet expectations that left many players feeling value was lacking at launch.[1][2] | +15 |
| For | Rushed development and leadership churn | Kotaku’s investigation and contemporaneous histories report that large parts of Anthem were reworked late and significant decisions were forced by deadlines, producing a rushed final product.[3] | +14 |
| For | Anthem NEXT overhaul cancelled | BioWare officially announced in February 2021 that it had stopped development on the Anthem NEXT rework and would keep only the live service running in its current state.[5][4] | +12 |
| Against | Notable technical and design strengths | Contemporaneous reviews praised Anthem’s flight mechanics, visuals, and combat feel, showing substantial production craft in parts of the game.[1][6] | -10 |
| For | Demo and launch technical problems | The VIP demo and early access periods experienced server and stability problems and BioWare issued day‑one patches to address load times and crashes, consistent with an unpolished launch.[7][8] | +9 |
Confidence: High · Findings are supported by multiple reputable sources including Kotaku, GameSpot, BioWare’s own blog, Bloomberg, and Game Informer; gaps remain around exact in‑game store price points and internal EA profitability targets which were not publicly disclosed. · Researched 2026-07-24
Sources reviewed
- [1]www.gamespot.com
- [2]www.metacritic.com
- [3]kotaku.com
- [4]www.bloomberg.com
- [5]blog.bioware.com
- [6]kotaku.com
- [7]www.gamespot.com
- [8]www.gamespot.com
- [9]ir.ea.com
- [10]kotaku.com
View 153 more sourcesShow fewer sources
- [11]www.pushsquare.com
- [12]www.sciencedirect.com
- [13]gameinformer.com
- [14]arstechnica.com
- [15]en.wikipedia.org
- [16]www.prosport.ro
- [17]journals.sagepub.com
- [18]www.gamestar.de
- [19]www.gamepro.de
- [20]www.reddit.com
- [21]en.wikipedia.org
- [22]www.reddit.com
- [23]www.reddit.com
- [24]www.reddit.com
- [25]www.reddit.com
- [26]en.wikipedia.org
- [27]www.reddit.com
- [28]www.reddit.com
- [29]ultimatepopculture.fandom.com
- [30]handwiki.org
- [31]everything.explained.today
- [32]www3.stats.govt.nz
- [33]autaski.com
- [34]fliphtml5.com
- [35]www.balanta.org
- [36]www.joelballezza.com
- [37]www.scribd.com
- [38]softpanorama.org
- [39]anglo-magyar-media.com
- [40]www.scribd.com
- [41]www.reddit.com
- [42]www.videogameschronicle.com
- [43]www.bungie.net
- [44]esportimes.com
- [45]www.rpgfan.com
- [46]gamingbolt.com
- [47]www.pcmrace.com
- [48]www.reddit.com
- [49]www.trueachievements.com
- [50]thehyperbolicgamer.com
- [51]www.reddit.com
- [52]gamingbolt.com
- [53]www.reddit.com
- [54]gamingbolt.com
- [55]gaming.news
- [56]www.reddit.com
- [57]www.reddit.com
- [58]www.everyeye.it
- [59]www.reddit.com
- [60]www.reddit.com
- [61]www.reddit.com
- [62]www.pcgamesn.com
- [63]www.forbes.com
- [64]www.nme.com
- [65]www.thesixthaxis.com
- [66]www.playstationlifestyle.net
- [67]www.forbes.com
- [68]www.jeuxvideo.com
- [69]attackofthefanboy.com
- [70]www.engadget.com
- [71]jagatplay.com
- [72]www.mmorpg.com
- [73]www.reddit.com
- [74]www.reddit.com
- [75]en.wikipedia.org
- [76]www.reddit.com
- [77]gameinformer.com
- [78]www.pushsquare.com
- [79]gameinformer.com
- [80]www.playstationlifestyle.net
- [81]gameinformer.com
- [82]gameinformer.com
- [83]www.dlcompare.co.uk
- [84]gameinformer.com
- [85]www.playstationlifestyle.net
- [86]eduardobutton.wordpress.com
- [87]www.pcgamesn.com
- [88]www.reddit.com
- [89]www.reddit.com
- [90]www.reddit.com
- [91]www.reddit.com
- [92]toppodcast.com
- [93]indie.rpgwatch.com
- [94]news.ycombinator.com
- [95]hardforum.com
- [96]s3-euw1-ap-pe-df-pch-content-store-p.s3.eu-west-1.amazonaws.com
- [97]knowyourmeme.com
- [98]www.forum-3dcenter.org
- [99]journals.suub.uni-bremen.de
- [100]s3-euw1-ap-pe-df-pch-content-store-p.s3.eu-west-1.amazonaws.com
- [101]forums.crateentertainment.com
- [102]www.metacritic.com
- [103]www.metacritic.com
- [104]www.metacritic.com
- [105]www.metacritic.com
- [106]www.metacritic.com
- [107]www.metacritic.com
- [108]www.metacritic.com
- [109]www.reddit.com
- [110]thegeek.games
- [111]legacy.prod.metacritic.com
- [112]legacy.prod.metacritic.com
- [113]steamcommunity.com
- [114]www.reddit.com
- [115]www.reddit.com
- [116]www.reddit.com
- [117]www.reddit.com
- [118]www.reddit.com
- [119]www.reddit.com
- [120]www.reddit.com
- [121]foguswebpage.wordpress.com
- [122]preisvergleich.heise.de
- [123]dewiki.de
- [124]dokumen.pub
- [125]de.wikipedia.org
- [126]geizhals.de
- [127]www.halopedia.org
- [128]geizhals.de
- [129]ffshrine.org
- [130]www.wikidata.org
- [131]gamefaqs.gamespot.com
- [132]thecomicbooks.com
- [133]boards.4chan.org
- [134]www.alternatehistory.com
- [135]www.gamespot.com
- [136]www.gamespot.com
- [137]www.gamespot.com
- [138]www.gamespot.com
- [139]www.gamespot.com
- [140]www.gamespot.com
- [141]www.gamespot.com
- [142]www.gamespot.com
- [143]www.gamespot.com
- [144]www.gamespot.com
- [145]www.gamesradar.com
- [146]www.ilxor.com
- [147]jackdawjournal.wixsite.com
- [148]dokumen.pub
- [149]dokumen.pub
- [150]podnews.net
- [151]www.techradar.com
- [152]wolfsgamingblog.com
- [153]www.gamespot.com
- [154]store.steampowered.com
- [155]ru.wikipedia.org
- [156]circleofnerds.com
- [157]my.priceme.com
- [158]www.forum-3dcenter.org
- [159]www.techradar.com
- [160]www.techradar.com
- [161]www.techradar.com
- [162]www.techradar.com
- [163]www.eurogamer.net
What does the community think?
The AI sees low cash-grab risk. What's your read?
Loading community verdict…